Monday, September 3, 2012

How not to evaluate a mutual fund scheme?

Often investors like showered with a lot of information on how to assess a mutual fund scheme but never are they guided on how not to evaluate a mutual fund scheme. PersonalFN highlights few points which many a times investors fail to consider while investing in a mutual fund scheme.

A lot of mutual fund advice/research now-a-days is focused on how investors must evaluate mutual funds. You must have come across a lot of literature on this in a newspaper or on websites of mutual fund houses. Even your distributor / relationship manager / agent must have showered you with a lot of information on how to assess a mutual fund scheme before investing in the same. Unfortunately, in our view that is often not enough. It is like knowing only half of the story, which then leads to mis-selling by self-centred distributor or advisors. As a result, a lot of investors who end up investing in mutual fund schemes which lacks consistency in performance are left very disillusioned with how their investments have performed. All this can be prevented if investors are armed with two golden rules to invest in mutual funds "guidelines on how to evaluate a mutual fund" and just as importantly "guidelines on how not to evaluate a mutual fund". Over here let us discuss the other half of the story i.e., guidelines on how not to evaluate a mutual fund which is generally very less discussed about.

1. Don't read too much into past performance
Read any mutual fund advertisement and there is likely to be a mention of the funds incredible performance over the years. At times the focus on past performance is so overwhelming that it leaves you with the impression that, past performance is all that matters while investing in a mutual fund. However, in our view, past performance is important, but it is just one of the factors that must be considered while investing in a mutual fund scheme. Among other factors that rarely find a mention in advertisements are the fund houses investment philosophy and processes, level of ethics, performance across market phases especially during the downturns of the stock markets. 

2. Don't read too much into mutual fund ratings
In our view, mutual fund ratings get more than their share of attention from investors, which is unfortunate. This is especially true since in the Indian context mutual fund ratings are often biased towards returns with little or no room for evaluating among other factors, the fund house's investment philosophy, processes, track record on transparency, consistency, compliance and ethics. Such lopsided ratings cannot be the base for investors to take a decision whether to buy or sell or hold a particular mutual fund scheme. However, ratings can be considered as a reference point while evaluating different types of mutual fund schemes.

3. Don't read too much into CAGR performance
One of the many selling points for mutual funds is their performance in terms of compounded annualised growth rate (CAGR). Any student of mathematics can confirm this "CAGR is just an indicator of growth between two points" (or between two dates as in the case of a mutual fund investment). It tells you nothing about what transpired in the interval and more importantly it tells you nothing about the risk the mutual fund has exposed investors to and the investment process that generated that CAGR. At the end, the CAGR hides more than it reveals which is why investors should not read more in it than necessary.

4. Don't invest in a mutual fund just because its NAV is low
Many a times you perceive investment in a New Fund Offer (NFO) as a good investment just because the NFO is priced at Rs 10. On a similar footing, even existing mutual funds with lower Net Asset Value (NAV) appeal you more as compared to a mutual fund with a higher NAV. In our view, this approach to selecting a mutual fund is absolutely incorrect. Let us understand what constitutes or how NAV of a mutual fund is arrived at. The NAV of a mutual fund is expressed as total of all assets of the particular scheme less the liabilities of that scheme (excluding liability towards unit holders), divided by the total number of outstanding units.

Thus, when you invest in a mutual fund you invest at its existing NAV wherein you buy units at a price (i.e. the NAV). The calculation of the NAV is based on the current market price of all the assets that the mutual fund scheme owns less the liabilities. In other words, the NAV represents the mutual fund scheme's intrinsic value.

Unlike in stocks, wherein the stock price of a company is different from its intrinsic value due to fact that the investors evaluate the company's future profitability and accordingly pay a higher price or lower price as compared to its book value. This does not hold true for open-ended mutual funds - they always trade at their book value; so investors never buy them cheap or expensive in that sense.

5. Don't count on the star fund manager
Unlike other factors like past performance that merit some (positive) consideration, the presence of a star fund manager merits no such consideration. On the contrary a fund house must be given negative marks for attributing its success to a star fund manager. While over the short-term a star fund manager may bring about a dramatic change in the mutual fund's performance, over the long-term he can do more harm than good.

As a mutual fund's performance gets inseparably linked with the presence of the star fund manager, his existence in the fund house becomes a prerequisite for the fund's success. If the star fund manager quits the fund house, it could leave the fund and its investors in the lurch because the existing team is unlikely to be capacitated to deliver on the same lines as the star fund manager.

So what must investors do? Go for fund houses that institutionalize the fund management process by building teams that are guided by well-defined processes where individuals have a limited role to play.

6. Don't question every investment decision made by your fund manager
While it's good to be aware of what your fund manager is up to, it is only in the fitness of things that you let him do what he is good at doing, which is identifying the best investment opportunities ahead of the competition. As an investor you must do what you are supposed to do which is getting your financial planner involved in the process of keeping a tab on your investments. The financial planner (provided he is honest and competent) should be the one to tell you whether the fund manager is investing in line with his pre-determined investment mandate and philosophy. Once you understand the roles defined for all three parties over here "fund manager, financial planner and you", (i.e. the investor) you will not waste your time organizing over views like whether your fund manager is doing the right thing by investing in software stocks in the backdrop of a rising rupee and so on.

Thus, the next time you plan to invest in a mutual fund please take a note of the above 'must avoids' along with the guidelines on how to select a winning mutual fund for your portfolio.

Source: http://www.moneycontrol.com/news/mf-experts/how-not-to-evaluatemutual-fund-scheme_751874.html

Thursday, August 30, 2012

Reliance Capital launches SIP through SMS

Investors will be able to start a SIP by sending an SMS through their registered mobile numbers

Reliance Capital Asset Management (RCAM) today launched a systematic investment plan (SIP) in mutual funds through SMS under its 'Invest Easy' initiative.

As per the initiative, investors will be able to start a SIP by sending an SMS through their registered mobile numbers.

"SIP through SMS is the latest service offering from RCAM. This feature will make it cost efficient and convenient for over 900 million mobile users across the country to participate and make investments in mutual funds," Reliance Capital Asset Management chief executive Sundeep Sikka said in a statement.

This new feature has been launched under the company's 'Invest Easy' initiative, which aims to use technology for making it convenient for customers to invest in mutual funds.

"We already have over 2.5 lakh customers under the 'Invest Easy' initiative that allows investors to transact online on the net, on their mobiles, through call centres and now using SMS. A large number of our customers are already migrating to the online platform and we see this number growing exponentially through this facility," Sikka said.

He said the company would strengthen its reach among small-ticket investors through this initiative.

Source: http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/reliance-capital-launches-sip-through-sms/184565/on

Retention, not exit, will help fund houses

The already-struggling mutual fund industry has a new headache. According to the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s latest guidelines, the exit load that fund houses charge will be ploughed back into the scheme, and not to the balance sheet, as was done earlier.

This, on one hand, will improve the net asset values for investors who stay in the scheme. But fund houses’ balance sheets will lose out on one component of income.

While details of the guidelines are yet to be notified, industry players are already talking about reducing upfront fees to ensure there isn’t an adverse impact on their profit and loss accounts.

What will, of course, help them is the rise in the total expense ratio by 20 basis points, and an additional 30 basis points if the incremental increase in assets is from smaller cities.

According to the chief marketing officer of a large fund house, the net impact will be marginal but that can be taken care of, if industry adopts the new business model to bring down upfront commissions.

The exit load was meant as a deterrent for investors so that they did not leave the scheme in less than a year, in case of equities. Normally, one to two per cent is imposed based on the tenure of investment. “But exit of investors before investment duration also benefited AMCs as they used to get exit load amount besides helping distributors make money because of the churning,” he further explains.

“Though prima facie it appears that this arrangement of routing the exit load back to schemes may impact us. But since, the regulator has allowed us to charge extra 20 basis points and shifted the service tax out of the total expense ratio the impact will lessen,” says the chief executive officer (CEO) of a small-sized fund house who did not wish to be named. Already, only 15 out of 44 players made profits in 2011-12. Of this, four houses had profits of less than Rs 10 crore.

Fund houses have a bigger dilemma – whether to reward entry into schemes through an upfront commission or hike the trail commission to reward staying invested for a longer time.

“In today’s context, if I pay high upfront commission, what’s the guarantee that investors will remain with me. And, in case he moves out within a year, exit load collected will go to schemes and not the AMCs. So, I would lose the upfront as well as the exit load. Rather, I would increase trail commissions and reduce or phase out upfront fees,” added the CEO.

Most of the chief executives echoed this. Moreover, this kind of probable strategy is also in line with what majority of independent financial advisors (IFAs) want. If trail goes up, distributors will be encouraged to retain and service their clients for longer duration benefitting all stakeholders of the industry. Currently, on an average upfront fee ranges from 10 bps to 50 bps while trail commission is around 30-80 bps.

According to independent industry experts, large fund houses may not find it difficult to continue with higher up-front payouts as they are relatively better placed than smaller fund houses and new entrants in the fund management business.

In FY12, overall commission payouts to mutual fund distributors were 5 per cent higher at Rs 1,860 crore against Rs 1,770 crore in FY11.

Source: http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/retention-not-exit-will-help-fund-houses-/484834/

Saturday, August 25, 2012

Reliance Mutual Fund Invests In HT Media

Relaince Mutual Fund has invested around r13.05Cr in HT Media. The fund acquired 15,00,000 shares at R87 per share of HT Media through bulk deal on BSE.

Reliance Mutual Fund already holds 2.83% stake through Relliance Growth Fund account.

HT Media Ltd is an Indian mass media company based in Delhi, India. It publishes Hindustan Times, an English daily, and Mint, a business paper. It operates 19 printing facilities across India with an installed capacity of 1.5 Mn copies per hour.

HT Media had bought social networking site DesiMartini through its online subsidiary Firefly eVentures in 2007 and invested in Micro Technologies through 5 lakh CCD’s worth R20 Cr.

Source: http://www.dealcurry.com/20120824-Reliance-Mutual-Fund-Invests-In-HT-Media.htm

Friday, August 24, 2012

Benefit for direct investors in small MF schemes

Sebi guidelines will help the financial savvy and the ones still finding their feet in the stock markets.

The equity market regulator, the Securities and Exchange Board of India, has made it more profitable for direct mutual fund (MF) investors. In its recent guidelines, it has proposed to keep two net asset values (NAVs) in mutual fund schemes – one for the direct investor and another for the ones who come through distributors.

But, before going for the direct route, undertake a cost-benefit analysis. Though, the final difference in costs between a direct investor and one going through a distributor will only emerge when the numbers are actually declared by the fund houses, a little bit of number crunching can give us a ball park figure.

Currently, mutual funds charge up to 2.5 per cent as expenses. Add another 20 basis points to that and the investor will be paying around 2.7 per cent – the average expense for a smaller scheme of Rs 500-700 crore will be to the tune of 2.4 per cent.

Of this, for equity funds 1-1.25 per cent is charged as investment management fees, registration and transfer charges, custodian charges, investor communication (for printing half-yearly results), trustee fee, etc. All these will come to around 1.75-2 per cent. After all these expenses, the fund house will have 40-65 basis points that could be passed on to the investor.

For a larger size fund of Rs 3,000 crore, the numbers would be lower. The expense ratio for such schemes is to the tune of two per cent. So, direct investors will stand to gain very little in schemes that are managing large amounts. The savings will be from trail commissions that are paid to the distributors.

For someone who is investing Rs 1 lakh in an equity mutual scheme, the savings would be around Rs 500-700 annually. Direct investors were anyway exempt from paying any entry load (during the entry load regime). However, despite this benefit, still 95 per cent of mutual fund investors buy units through a distributor such as a bank, brokerage, financial planner and so on, say experts.

“At present, people don’t take the direct route because choosing a suitable mutual fund scheme and doing the necessary paperwork on their own is still quite a cumbersome process,” explains Jaideep Bhattacharya, managing director, Baroda Pioneer AMC.

From a retail investor’s perspective, there will be some savings. But what one needs to consider is – can they take the call on what is the best fund to invest in? The question is important because many put in money because some scheme is performing exceptionally well for a short period. And then get trapped in bad times. If you are unsure about the scheme, it is important that you should take professional help even at a cost.

Another move that will expand the investor base, is allowing people without a PAN card or a bank account to invest cash up to Rs 20,000 in MF schemes. At the moment, you need identity proof and bank account for any investment-related transactions. This move, fund experts say, will help people in Tier-IV, V and even VI cities.

Amar Ranu, senior manager (third party products), Motilal Oswal Private Wealth says the ones that are likely to take this route should invest in balanced funds, since they would be first-time investors. Within balanced funds, monthly income plans (MIPs) are a good option.

Investors can opt for both combinations – 65 per cent equity or debt – depending on their age and risk profile. In case of 65 per cent equities, the downside is higher in the present market conditions. In good market conditions, they do better than 65 per cent debt products.

Source: http://www.business-standard.com/india/news/benefit-for-direct-investors-in-small-mf-schemes/484240/

Just click away from joining most active Mutual Fund India google group

Google Groups
Subscribe to Mutual Fund india
Email:
Visit this group

Aggrasive Portfolio

  • Principal Emerging Bluechip fund (Stock picker Fund) 11%
  • Reliance Growth Fund (Stock Picker Fund) 11%
  • IDFC Premier Equity Fund (Stock picker Fund) (STP) 11%
  • HDFC Equity Fund (Mid cap Fund) 11%
  • Birla Sun Life Front Line Equity Fund (Large Cap Fund) 10%
  • HDFC TOP 200 Fund (Large Cap Fund) 8%
  • Sundram BNP Paribas Select Midcap Fund (Midcap Fund) 8%
  • Fidelity Special Situation Fund (Stock picker Fund) 8%
  • Principal MIP Fund (15% Equity oriented) 10%
  • IDFC Savings Advantage Fund (Liquid Fund) 6%
  • Kotak Flexi Fund (Liquid Fund) 6%

Moderate Portfolio

  • HDFC TOP 200 Fund (Large Cap Fund) 11%
  • Principal Large Cap Fund (Largecap Equity Fund) 10%
  • Reliance Vision Fund (Large Cap Fund) 10%
  • IDFC Imperial Equity Fund (Large Cap Fund) 10%
  • Reliance Regular Saving Fund (Stock Picker Fund) 10%
  • Birla Sun Life Front Line Equity Fund (Large Cap Fund) 9%
  • HDFC Prudence Fund (Balance Fund) 9%
  • ICICI Prudential Dynamic Plan (Dynamic Fund) 9%
  • Principal MIP Fund (15% Equity oriented) 10%
  • IDFC Savings Advantage Fund (Liquid Fund) 6%
  • Kotak Flexi Fund (Liquid Fund) 6%

Conservative Portfolio

  • ICICI Prudential Index Fund (Index Fund) 16%
  • HDFC Prudence Fund (Balance Fund) 16%
  • Reliance Regular Savings Fund - Balanced Option (Balance Fund) 16%
  • Principal Monthly Income Plan (MIP Fund) 16%
  • HDFC TOP 200 Fund (Large Cap Fund) 8%
  • Principal Large Cap Fund (Largecap Equity Fund) 8%
  • JM Arbitrage Advantage Fund (Arbitrage Fund) 16%
  • IDFC Savings Advantage Fund (Liquid Fund) 14%

Best SIP Fund For 10 Years

  • IDFC Premier Equity Fund (Stock Picker Fund)
  • Principal Emerging Bluechip Fund (Stock Picker Fund)
  • Sundram BNP Paribas Select Midcap Fund (Midcap Fund)
  • JM Emerging Leader Fund (Multicap Fund)
  • Reliance Regular Saving Scheme (Equity Stock Picker)
  • Biral Mid cap Fund (Mid cap Fund)
  • Fidility Special Situation Fund (Stock Picker)
  • DSP Gold Fund (Equity oriented Gold Sector Fund)